Skip to main content

MBA Essay First vs. Second Draft

First Draft

The first draft of an essay is messy with the applicant’s consciousness poured into the answer without structure, relevance, and sometimes missing the intent of the question. The flawed output could be discarded as a rambling of an applicant desperately seeking admissions. But through the process of pouring one’s heart out, the applicant touches upon points that missed the initial brainstorming sessions or captures a moment of vulnerability that breaks the ‘foolproof’ impression that one gets from the resume.

Without vulnerability, the essays are extended brag sheets with no context on how the applicant thinks, handles setbacks, and create imaginative solutions.

 

Applicants who are from a technical background – Technologists and Finance professionals, use the first draft as a structuring exercise, hiding their true motivation and taking great length to follow the standard template – define the problem, how we found the solution, implementation of the solution and the results. Unless you are working on the latest technology solution that is in the active consciousness of a general audience, the ‘cool’ solution will fail to associate your personal brand with the solution.
 
Let the first draft be messy with insecurities, idealistic values, and ambitious goals.

Should you share the first Draft with the MBA Admission Consultant?

MBA Admissions Consultants are like your therapist for 6 months with whom you share the innermost worries, aspirations, and goals. I have learned so much about function, industries, and technology from my clients. I have also been inspired by bright minds and the ones who never gave up despite looming life challenges.

Your thoughts, values, resilience, actions, and results define your brand. Don’t shy away from sharing your true persona.

 

I have found first drafts not just to capture a unique voice but also to have interesting life experiences that didn’t come out during the initial brainstorming session (IMPACT table creation and Resume Editing).
 
Share the first draft with the admissions consultants. A good consultant and editor will find structure from the free-flowing stream of consciousness.

Second Draft

Our editing mostly starts here.  From an unstructured narrative, we bring structure, relevance, and elements of storytelling to the narrative.

 

The first draft could include exposition of values that might be too soon or too late.
 
Some values look like random mentions without enough relevance.
 
Many lines would have Jargons that are limiting to the flow of the narrative.
 
Some applicants overexpose the background information with details that could never be captured in the essay.
 
Many fail to offer enough context on an event.
 
The follow-up questions, quoting a specific line, becomes an exercise for us to capture the background information, the constraints, and the opportunities.

After Draft – Editing

The real work starts after all the relevant information is captured in the Second Draft. Depending on the applicant’s work schedule, writing capability, and the school deadlines, editing could take anywhere from 1 to 5 days.

 

Through our iterative editing process, the random thoughts about an Essay Question transform to a Winning MBA Essay.
 

About the Author 

Atul Jose

I am Atul Jose, Founding Consultant of F1GMAT, an MBA admissions consultancy that has worked with applicants since 2009.

 

For the past 15 years I have edited the application files of admits to the M7 programs: Harvard Business School, Stanford Graduate School of Business, the Wharton School, MIT Sloan, Chicago Booth, Kellogg School of Management, and Columbia Business School, together with admits to Berkeley Haas, Yale School of Management, NYU Stern, Michigan Ross, Duke Fuqua, Darden, Tuck, IMD, London Business School, INSEAD, SDA Bocconi, IESE Business School, HEC Paris, McCombs, and Tepper, plus other programs inside the global top 30.

 

My work covers the full MBA application deliverable: career planning and profile evaluation, application essay editing, recommendation letter editing, mock interviews and interview preparation, scholarship and fellowship essay editing, and cover letter editing for funding applications. Full bio with credentials and admit history is here.

 

I am the author of the Winning MBA Essay Guide, the best-selling essay guide covering M7 MBA programs. I have written and updated the guide annually since 2013, which makes the 2026 edition the thirteenth.

 

The reason I still write and edit essays every cycle: a good MBA essay carries a real applicant's voice. Writing essays for F1GMAT's Books and Editing essays weekly is how I stay calibrated to what current admissions committees respond to.

 

Contact me for school selection, career planning, essay strategy, narrative development, essay editing, interview preparation, scholarship essay editing, or guidance documents for recommendation letters.