Second Tier B-Schools - Higher ROI than Ivy League Schools?

According to a recent study, the highest rates of return were found for the second-tier public business schools. The rate of return for Michigan State (Broad) was 42.72 percent. For Illinois (Urbana-Champaign), it was 42.33 percent, and for Iowa (Tippy), it was 39.7 percent.  Contrast this with the rate of return for Harvard Business School, which was only 19.7 percent. The University of Chicago (Booth School of Business) was in the last place with only a 13.4 percent rate of return.

How the Study was conducted?

The new study estimated the rate of return for the top 30 MBA programs and 15 second-tier MBA programs in the United States by comparing the cost of degree acquisition with the incremental post-MBA income over an expected work life of 40 years. Tuition and fees and two years of foregone income were used as the cost of the investment. The incremental salary was calculated and used as the investment’s cash inflows.

Reasons for high ROI for Second Tier Public Business Schools

According to the study, these high returns can be credited to two distinct aspects of their programs.

First, the tuition and fees are generally less than their private counterparts. For instance, Michigan State’s in-state tuition and fees are $29,359 for two years, and only $58,365 for a non-resident. Chicago and Harvard, on the other hand, are $97,165 and $101,660, respectively – for the same two-year period. The median tuition for Business Week’s top 15 programs is $93,568, while the median tuition for the fifteen second-tier schools is $72,184. The higher required investment reduces the rate of return for a common cash flow. But all MBAs are not created alike. Indeed, the median post-MBA income for a Chicago graduate is $105,000 per year, while the Harvard median salary is $121,000. The median post-MBA salary from the top 15 programs is $110,000.

Importance of Pre-MBA Salary in ROI Calculations

The second-tier schools have a median post-MBA income of $90,000, only three of the second-tier schools report post-MBA incomes of above $90,000. Likewise, the students are not homogeneous in terms of background. The schools that are higher-ranked attract students that are leaving jobs that are higher-paying than those taken by their counterparts who attend the second-tier schools. Business Week’s top 15 schools have a median pre-MBA income of $70,000, while the second-tier median is only $45,000 before their MBA.

Since the incremental cash inflow from an investment in an MBA is the differential between the pre- and post-MBA salary, the top ranked programs are victimized by their success. Highly-ranked programs tend to attract students that are more experienced and that have already achieved success in higher-paying positions. The median incremental gain in income (the difference between post MBA salary and pre-MBA salary) was $35,000 for the top-ranked programs, but $40,000 for the schools in the second tier.

Second-tier schools have a rate of return that is consistently higher than that of top-tier schools. The correlation coefficient between the IRR and the percentage change in income (pre-MBA vs post-MBA) is 92 percent.

Higher Post-MBA Salary

The median income for an entering student at the University of Pennsylvania (Wharton) was $80,000, with an expected median IRR of 18.36 percent over that student’s 40-year career. Had this student been persuaded by the higher IRR and enrolled at the University of Michigan, he/she could have expected a median post-MBA salary of only $93,000. However, a candidate accepted by Wharton that instead chose to attend Michigan State would have given up an $80,000 pre-MBA salary to earn only $93,000 two years later. A Michigan State MBA would yield this candidate an IRR of only 12.45 percent if he/she qualifies for in-state tuition and only an 11.44 percent return if he/she must pay non-resident rates. This is considerably less than the 18.36 percent associated with an MBA from Wharton. Thus, it appears that it is quite rational for students leaving higher-paying positions to gravitate toward the programs with the higher post-MBA salaries.

Weaknesses of the Study

First of all, salary data do not include the value of options and bonuses that may occur in the future. These additional sources of income can be very significant and could increase IRR results for top-tier MBA graduates, who are more likely to get jobs that pay higher bonuses.

Secondly, the study did not take into account the quality of the positions achieved nor the job satisfaction of the graduates.  While return on investment is an important factor,  job satisfaction and quality of the job are also important for MBA applicants to consider when making their school choices.

Source:  Estimating the Internal Rate of Return on an MBA: A Comparison of the Return from Top-Ranked &Second-Tier Programs by John B.  White, Ph.D. Professor of Finance, United States Coast Guard Academy; Morgan P. Miles, D.B.A. Professor of Enterprise  Development, University of Tasmania; Roger M. White, University of Pittsburgh.

Author : 

ZoomInterviewsZoomInterviews provides premium MBA admissions interview videos and preparation. It offer video examples of admissions interviews featuring students from top schools, video guidance for answering the most challenging interview questions and serve as a complete source for all your interview preparation needs.

Learn More about ZoomInterviews

2019 MBA Research Guide - Choose your MBA

"I attended three MBA Tours in US and Canada. I could just scratch the surface compared to what the guide has included. Thank you guys for the amazing book"

F1GMAT's Comprehensive MBA Research Guide will teach you how to select MBA programs through a bottom-up approach. 

Articulating your Post-MBA Goals and Career Path is the FIRST step. Which program will give you that hike in Salary, Switch in Career, Change in Location or Job Satisfaction?

We cover them all through our extensive analysis. 

Pages: 500

+ How to Choose the Best MBA Program: Factors to Consider
Define Post-MBA Goals
Pick your Path: Generalize or Specialize
Use Moral Algebra Method 
Use Multi-Attribute Utility Theory
Understand the Top 5 Risks
Measure MBA Career Service Team's Effectiveness
Use Bookending to Calculate MBA Admission Chance
Use Net Present Value to Calculate MBA Return on Investment
Don't Fall for the Mere Exposure Effect
Best Practices to find the truth in MBA Information Session or MBA Tour

Comprehensive MBA Research Guide:
Top MBA Programs by 19 Specializations:
+ General Management
+ Finance
+ Consulting
+ Marketing
+ Strategy
+ Operations Management
+ Supply Chain Management
+ Luxury Management
+ Information Systems
+ Hospitality Management
+ Accounting
+ Energy
+ Non-Profit
+ Wine
+ Sports
+ Sustainability
+ Leadership Development
+ Military &
+ International

+ Top MBA Program Ranking
Top 20 MBA Programs - Tuition Fee (2018)    
Top 31 MBA Programs in United States – Total Cost & Salary (2017)    

Top 60 MBA – GMAT and GPA (Average & Median)
Top 20 European MBA Programs - Tuition Fee, Total Cost & Salary    
Top 20 European MBA Programs (Based on Actual Salary Increase)    
Top 20 European MBA Programs (Short-term return on investment)    
Top 20 Affordable European MBA Programs    
Top 10 MBA in UK – Salary & Fee (2018)  
Top MBA Destinations Based on Happiness Index    
Top MBA Destinations based on Innovation Index    
Top 10 MBA Job Markets based on Cost of living and Purchasing Power    
Top MBA Destination: By Economy    

+Comparisons - Top MBA Programs
Wharton vs. Columbia MBA (2018)  
MIT vs. Stanford MBA   (2017)
Haas vs. Ross MBA    
Kellogg vs Ross MBA    
Booth vs Wharton MBA    
MIT Sloan vs Tuck MBA    
IIMA vs. ISB   

Harvard vs. Stanford MBA (2017)

+ MBA in France (2018)
Top Industries in France   
Top MBA Programs in France  

  Class Profile   
  Post-MBA Salary

Scholarships in France
External Funding 

+ MBA in the UK (2018)
Top Industries in the UK   
Top MBA Programs in the UK

  Class Profile   
  Post-MBA Salary

Scholarships in the UK
External Funding 

New Visa Rules: Post-Brexit

Download F1GMAT's MBA Research Guide (2019)

Navigate F1GMAT

F1GMAT Services (MBA Applicants) 

F1GMAT's Books

MBA Salary(Latest Salary Data)
MBA Admission Interview Tips



MBA Application Essays

MBA Recommendation Letter

GMAT Tutorials

GMAT Question Bank

Top MBA Programs

Get F1GMAT's Newsletters (Best in the Industry)
Included in the Newsletter:

  • Ranking Analysis
  • Post-MBA Salary Trends
  • Post-MBA Job Function & Industry Analysis
  • Post-MBA City Review
  • MBA Application Essay Tips
  • School Specific Essay Tips
  • GMAT Preparation Tips
  • MBA Admission Interview Tips
  • School Specific Interview Tips
  • Funding Guidance and
  • Special Consultation Service (only for Subscribers)

Subscribe to F1GMAT's Newsletter