How to overcome flawed thinking in GMAT Critical Reasoning?

Flawed Thinking in GMAT Critical Reasoning
Critical Reasoning is a skill that you cannot develop in a couple of days. But GMAT Critical reasoning can be mastered if you understand some of the common pitfalls in our logical deduction. The most common mistakes are made in Syllogism.

What is Syllogism?

A Syllogism is a type of argument where you have a conclusion based on one or more premises. Let’s look at an example

Premise 1: All roses are flowers

Premise 2: Some flowers have thorn

Conclusion: Therefore Some roses have thorn

Most GMAT test taker would agree with the conclusion or naturally make such conclusions when they are presented with similar critical reasoning questions. The CONCLUSION is wrong! We are intuitive creatures. Even when our logical mind asks us to think before making any conclusion, the lazy intuitive mind will force us to make the obvious wrong conclusion. Another factor that contributes to the wrong conclusion is the use of our knowledge about roses (that it has thorns) to make the conclusion.

Remember, GMAT Critical reasoning requires you to make conclusion purely based on the premises provided.

How to overcome flaws in logical thinking for GMAT Critical Reasoning Questions?

The trick here is to identify the terms used in the Syllogism

There are three terms: Major Term, Minor Term and Middle Term

Premise having Major Term is the Major Premise

Premise having Minor Term is the Minor Premise

How to identify Major and Minor Terms?

The subject of the conclusion is the Minor Term

Conclusion: Therefore Some roses have thorn

Subject = Roses = Minor Term

Predicate Term or category/concept used to describe the subject is the Major Term

Predicate Term = Thorn = Major Term

Where does the minor term (roses) appear?

Premise 1: All roses are flowers
Premise 1 = Minor Premise

Where does the major term (Thorn) appear?

Premise 2: Some flowers have thorn
Premise 2 = Major Premise

Which term does not feature in the conclusion but plays an important role in the logical deduction?

Flowers = Middle Term

What is the use of understanding types of terms and premises?

By familiarizing yourself with the terms and premises, it would become much easier to solve GMAT Critical Reasoning questions.


Here we go:

Premise 1: All roses are flowers
Premise 2: Some flowers have thorn
Conclusion: Therefore Some roses have thorn

Step by Step Instructions to Solve GMAT Critical Reasoning Tricky Questions

1) Identify absolute premise (Arguments with “All”, “None”)

Absolute Premise: Premise 1

2) Represent the terms as alphabets

Roses = Minor Term = C
Flowers = Middle Term = B
Thorn = Major Term = A

All C in B
Some B in A
Therefore Some C in A

3) Draw Venn Diagrams starting with the absolute premise first.

Absolute Premise = All C in B             

All C in B                                                              

4) Next Premise

Some B in A

5)  Two ways to present Some B in A

Case 1: Some B intersecting A without intersecting C

Some B in A
Case 2: Some B in A such that A and C intersects

Some B in C Intersecting A

Conclusion: Some C in A

Not necessarily true

Conclusion is wrong. The conclusion should be true for all conditions. In this case it is false for Case 1

It is tough to go through so many steps to solve a simple GMAT CR Question in a minute.

True. But once you practice with Venn diagrams, your knowledge about a subject or intuitive traps will not affect your ability to make correct conclusions.

Download Mastering GMAT Critical Reasoning

You know why GMAT test takers score in the low 600s or never cross the 700+ mark?

They fail to look at critical reasoning as a scoring opportunity. GMAT Critical Reasoning is not a puzzle. There is no extra point in getting to the answer without using Process of Elimination. You are wasting your time overanalyzing the answer choices or posting your findings in GMAT Forums. The so-called Critical Reasoning experts know the answer. Justifying an answer choice is much easier.

F1GMAT’s Mastering GMAT Critical Reasoning E-Book will take the mystery out of critical reasoning questions.

Find out How>>

Essential GMAT Reading Comprehension Guide

After you read F1GMAT’s Essential GMAT Reading Comprehension Guide, you will:

1. Complete GMAT RC Questions in less than 1 minute and 50 seconds

2. Read Faster

3. Take Notes Effectively

4. Collect and Interpret Facts

5. Speed up Summary Creation

6. Remember Information

7. Question the Author   

8. Learn to answer GMAT Reading Comprehension Title question   

9. Learn to Solve GMAT Reading Comprehension Main Idea Question   

10.Learn to Solve GMAT Reading comprehension inference question   

11. Learn to Solve GMAT Reading Comprehension Detail Questions   

12. Learn to Organize passage in GMAT Reading Comprehension   

13. Learn to Identify style/tone or attitude of the author

14. Learn to Improve GMAT Reading Comprehension Score

Download Essential GMAT Reading Comprehension Guide

Mastering GMAT Critical Reasoning

After you read F1GMAT’s Mastering GMAT Critical Reasoning Guide, you will:

1) Learn to eliminate out of scope answer choices

2) Learn to spot logical fallacies

3) Learn to read questions by focusing on the holy trinity – premise, assumption, and conclusion.

4) Learn to disregard filler information

5) Complete GMAT CR Questions in less than 1 minute and 40 seconds

Download Mastering GMAT Critical Reasoning

Navigate F1GMAT

F1GMAT Services (MBA Applicants) 

MBA Research

MBA Salary(Latest Salary Data)
MBA Admission Interview Tips



MBA Application Essays

GMAT Tutorials

GMAT Question Bank

Top MBA Programs

Get F1GMAT's Newsletters (Best in the Industry)
Included in the Newsletter:

  • Ranking Analysis
  • Post-MBA Salary Trends
  • Post-MBA Job Function & Industry Analysis
  • Post-MBA City Review
  • MBA Application Essay Tips
  • School Specific Essay Tips
  • GMAT Preparation Tips
  • MBA Admission Interview Tips
  • School Specific Interview Tips
  • Funding Guidance and
  • Special Consultation Service (only for Subscribers)

Subscribe to F1GMAT's Newsletter